top of page

Main Menu

All options served daily. Entrees are for dinner service only.



Small Plates

These dishes are great for sharing.




Tavern Nachos

Tortilla chips layered with brisket, cheddar cheese, pico, crema, fresh jalapeños & cilantro. (GF)

$17

Gluten free


Ahi Crunch

Yellowfin tuna with cucumber, mango, siracha, wasabi mayo, and avocado atop baked wontons. (Available GF)

$18

Available Gluten Free


Fried Pickles

Spears of dill pickles, breaded and fried. Served with a side of spicy ranch dipping sauce.

$12



Crab Rangoon Dip

Fresh crab meat, cream cheese, scallions, and sweet chili dip served with wontons. (Available GF)

$14

Available Gluten Free


Stuffed Hot Peppers

Three-cheese & Italian sausage stuffed Hungarian hot peppers with cheddar & marinara and garlic toast. (Available GF)

$16

Available Gluten Free


Hot Bavarian Pretzel

Hot, soft, buttery pretzel with homemade beer cheese and honey mustard sauces.

$12



Honey Sesame Chicken Lettuce Wraps

Bibb lettuce, Asian slaw, with a helping of our honey sesame chicken. (GF)

$16

Gluten free


Quesadilla

Flour tortilla filled with cherry peppers, cheese & chicken or steak. Folded & grilled. Served with hot dipping sauce.

Chicken

$17


Steak

$20



Blackened Shrimp Tacos

Corn or flour tortillas with blackened shrimp, roasted corn, banana peppers, avocado, and jalapeño ranch. (Sub Ahi Tuna +$2)

$18

Available Gluten Free


Smoked St. Louis Ribs

Hickory-smoked BBQ ribs with coleslaw. (GF)

$16



1812 Tavern Chips

Housemade chips with our favorite seasoning. Served with chipotle aioli. (GF)

$8

Gluten free



Soups

Rich, delicious, classic.




French Onion

Topped with melted provolone cheese and broiled to perfection. Crock only.

$10



New Orleans Gumbo

Chicken, shrimp, and andouille sausage served with white rice. Cup or bowl. GF

Cup

$8


Bowl

$10

Gluten free


Soup Du Jour

Cup or Bowl. Ask your server for daily variety.

Cup

$6


Bowl

$8




Salads

Fresh, crisp, light. Plus, turn any salad into a wrap! All House Made Dressings: Greek, Italian, Ranch, Bleu, Caesar, Lime Vinaigrette, Jalapeño Ranch, French, Balsamic




Side

Romaine lettuce with cheese, tomato, cucumber, and onion. (GF)

$8

Gluten free


Caesar

Romaine with Caesar dressing, garlic croutons, and parmesan cheese. (Available GF) Add salmon (+$8) or chicken (+$6)

Small

$10


Large

$12



Greek

Romaine, Greek dressing, feta, tomato, cucumber, banana peppers, red onions, green peppers—served with a warm pita. (Available GF) Add chicken (+$6) or steak (+$8)

$14

Available Gluten Free


Arugula & Apple

Sliced apples, glazed walnuts, fried goat cheese fritters atop arugula with a lemon vinaigrette. (GF) Add chicken (+$6)

$14

Gluten free


Pittsburgh

Romaine topped with chicken or steak, french fries, cheddar cheese, egg, tomato, with warm Riviera dressing. (GF)

Chicken

$18


Steak

$20

Gluten free


Buffalo Chicken Cobb

Medium chicken fingers, mixed greens, egg, cheddar cheese, bacon, tomato, avocado served with bleu cheese dressing. (Available GF)

$18



Southwest

Mixed greens, cheddar, tomato, onion, cherry peppers, roasted corn, and avocado in a crispy tortilla bowl with jalapeño ranch. Add chicken (+$6) or shrimp (+$8)

$15




Sandwiches

All served with chips or fries. Upgrade sides +$2. Side salad +$4. Gluten-free rolls or bread available upon request (+$2). All burgers can be substituted for grilled chicken or meatloaf.




The Workout

Pan-seared yellow fin tuna steak on a toasted Costanzo’s roll with shoestring fried onions and cranberry mayo.

$18



Beef on Weck

Roast beef layered on a Buffalo kummelweck roll. Served with horseradish.

$18



Texas Brisket

House smoked beef brisket, sliced, on a toasted Costanzo’s roll with slaw, pickled red onions, and Hickory sauce.

$16



Italian Sausage

Homemade Italian sausage patty with sweet peppers and onions on a Costanzo’s roll with melted mozzarella cheese.

$18



NY Steak

Steak with grilled peppers & onions on a toasted Costanzo’s roll with provolone. Add stuffed banana pepper (+$4)

$22



Turkey Club

Layers of turkey breast, white American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on three slices of toasted sourdough bread.

$16



Southtown Chicken

Crispy Nashville-style chicken, coleslaw, ghost pepper aiolo, and pepper jack cheese on a brioche bun.

$18



Portabello Mushroom Sandwich

Marinated and grilled with roasted red peppers, crumbly bleu cheese & pesto mayo served on a Costanzo’s roll.

$16



House Burger

10 oz. premium ground beef with cheddar cheese, bacon-tomato-onion jam served on a toasted Costanzo’s roll.

$18



Tavern Burger

10 oz. premium ground beef with provolone, mushrooms, onions & Guinness steak sauce on a toasted Costanzo’s roll.

$18



Ring of Fire Burger

10 oz. premium ground beef with cajun seasoning, chipotle mayo, pepperjack cheese, jalapeños & onion rings served on a toasted Costanzo’s roll.

$18




Pizza, Wings & Fingers

All pizzas are 10 inches. Regular or gluten-free cauliflower crust available. All pizzas can be made Detroit-style.




Cheese Pizza

Housemade pizza sauce, melted mozzarella, and our blend of herbs and spices Add pepperoni +$2.

Regular

$16


Pepperoni

$18



White Pizza

Grilled chicken, spinach, and tomatoes on a white garlic base.

$18



Brisket Pizza

Smoked brisket, white BBQ sauce, cheddar, and tobacco onions.

$20



Spicy Sausage

Hot peppers, spicy sausage, green peppers, and crispy onions.

$20



Chicken Wings

10/20/30 wings. Pick your sauce: mild, medium, hot, extra hot, honey mustard, BBQ, sweet chili, garlic parm, salt & vinegar dry rub, Murph’s, or spicy garlic parm. All served with a side of bleu cheese. SMOKED WINGS: +$2 Hickory or Jamaican Jerk Extra bleu cheese $1.50. Can’t split sauce with 10 ct.

10

$16


20

$30


30

$42



Chicken Fingers

Small 4, Large 6. Served with fries. Pick your sauce: mild, medium, hot, extra hot, honey mustard, BBQ, sweet chili, garlic parm, salt & vinegar dry rub, Murph’s, or spicy garlic parm.

Small

$15


Large

$20




Entrees

Dinner only. Gluten-free pasta available for all dishes upon request.




Cajun Chicken

Chicken & andouille sausage. Shallots, peppers, onions, and tomatoes. Fusilli pasta tossed in cream sauce. (Available GF)

$26

Available Gluten Free


Chicken or Salmon Risotto

Sautéed asparagus and chicken breast or salmon over a bed of Parmesan cheese risotto. GF

Chicken

$28


Salmon

$30

Gluten free


Chicken Milanese

Lightly breaded, pan-cooked chicken cutlet. Served with arugula, red onion, tomato, cucumber, and parm cheese tossed in a lemon vinaigrette. (Available GF)

$28

Available Gluten Free


Steak Frittes

8 oz. Sirloin steak, fries, and asparagus. GF

$25

Gluten free


Black & Bleu Filet

6 oz. blackened filet mignon stuffed with spinach and bleu cheese served with garlic mashed potatoes and asparagus. GF

$38

Gluten free


Pork Chop

12 oz. chop with honey thyme glaze served with garlic mashed potatoes and asparagus. GF

$28

Gluten free



Sides

Full $6 | Upgrade $2




French Fries

$6

Gluten free


Side Salad

$6

Gluten free


Grilled Vegetables

$6

Gluten free


Tuna Mac with Carrots + Peas

$4



Onion Rings

$6



Potato Chips

$6

Gluten free



Desserts

Brought to you by Sweet Pea Bakery




Pie

Pick your pie slice! Flavors rotate seasonally. All available gluten-free. Add vanilla ice cream +$1.

$9.50

Available Gluten Free


Cheesecake

Flavors rotate seasonally, ask your server! Both available gluten-free.

$9.50

Available Gluten Free


Butter Cake

Hot, gooey, and delicious. Available as a gluten-free dessert option.

$9.50

Available Gluten Free


Ice Cream Sandwich

Vanilla or peanut butter. Available gluten-free.

$9.50

Available Gluten Free


Flourless Chocolate Cake

Dense and delectable with rich, dark chocolate flavor. Gluten-free.

$9.50

Gluten free



Specialty Drinks




Blood Orange Spicy Paloma

Astral tequila, blood orange syrup, jalapeño, grapefruit + soda

$14



Cucumber Jalapeño Margarita

21 Seeds cucumber tequila, lime juice + triple sec

$14



Autumn Mule

Wheatley vodka, fig syrup + ginger beer

$14



Noel's Hugo Spritz

St. Germain, Prosecco, soda + fresh mint

$14



1812 Manhattan

1792 bourbon, sweet vermouth + bitters

$14



Old Fashioned

Sazerac rye, simple syrup, orange + Luxardo cherries

$14



Negroni

Farmer’s Botanical gin, Campari + sweet vermouth

$14



Duffy's Summer Drink

Stoli Orange, soda water, whisper of cranberry + orange slice

$9



The General

Riff bourbon, lemonade + bitters

$9



The Birdie

Tito’s + Purple Gatorade Zero

$9




Wine, Beer & Other

Stay cool in the summer and warm up with a drink in the winter. Your favorites all year long!




Kenwood Pinot Noir

$13



BR Cohn Cabernet

$13



Familia Vicente Pearce Malbec

$13



Josh Cabernet

$13



Sonoma Cutrer Chardonnay

$14



Hess Chardonnay

$9



Coppola Shimmer

$9



Torresella Pinot Grigio

$9



Dr. Frank Riesling

$13



Whispering Angel Rose

$13



Matua Sauvignon Blanc

$13



Miller High Life Ponies

$2.50



$4 Bottles & Cans

Genny (16oz.) Busch Light (16oz.)

$4



$5 Bottle of Beer

Corona & Corona Premier Pacifico Red Stripe Modelo

$5



$6 Bottle of Beer

Southern Tier IPA Athletic Run Wild IPA (NA)

$6



Craft Beer in Cans

Two Towns Pineapple Cider ($8) Dawg Pounders ($6) Sloop Juice Bomb ($8)Grimm Wavetable IPA ($10) Froth Bomb Sour ($10)Big Ditch Hayburner ($6) Big Ditch Strawberry Sour ($6) Aurora Little Lobster IPA ($10) Wayland Full Send ($9) Lawson’s Fest Bier ($9) Aurora Fresh To Death ($10) Gluten Free: Ghostfish Kick Step, Grapefruit, or Meteor Shower ($6)



$8 Can Seltzers & Cocktails

High Noon, Lucky One, Nütrl Good Boy, Welch’s, Surfside Suncruiser

$8



42 North Soulshine (Citrus Lager)

$7



Ultra

$5



Yuengling

$5



EBC Blueberry

$7



Wayland Waylander (German Pilsner)

$7



Sierra Nevada Pale Ale

$7



Sam Adams Summer Ale

$7



Southern Tier Pumking

$8



Main Lunch

$9



42 Craftsman Lager

$7



Wicked Weed Pernicious

$8



Prison City Mass Riot

$8



Guinness 20oz

$9


5381 Abbott Road , Hamburg, NY, United States, New York

© 1812 Tavern

bottom of page